Why Choose The Nutty Peanut

The Nutty Peanut is 100% Natural - Small Batch - Craft Peanut Butter. So what does that even mean? Well, we source only Natural ingredients for all of our nut butters, everything is Gluten, Soy, and Dairy free. Also we're Vegan friendly and GMO free, we also use some super healthy staple ingredients in every batch. (more on that below)  Small Batch means each jar is made with care at our Nutty Peanut Kitchen in Sanford, Florida, we don't use large processing machinery or pump out jar after jar on the assembly line, even the labels are put on by hand. Craft Peanut Butter has everything to do with the love and creativity we put into each recipe, we've tried hundreds of versions, a ton of crazy variations and if anything we are never short on new ideas. We look forward to offering new flavors as well as seasonal spreads ( like Pumpkin Spice & Gingerbread) in the future. We THANK YOU for choosing The Nutty Peanut. Welcome to Team Nutty. If you have any questions please reach out to us at

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

What makes The Nutty Peanut Different From Other Brands?
The Nutty Peanut is 100% Natural - Small Batch - Craft Peanut Butter.
So what does that even mean?
Well, we searched High and Low to find the finest combination of peanuts using multiple sources to create a unique flavor exclusive to The Nutty Peanut. Also, we only use Natural ingredients for all of our nut butters, everything is Gluten, Soy, Dairy and PALM OIL free. We're Vegan friendly, GMO free and we super boost every batch with healthy ingredients (find out more above) you won't find in the average jar.

Small Batch means each jar is made with care at our Nutty Peanut Kitchen in Sanford, Florida, we don't use large processing machinery or pump out jar after jar on the assembly line, even the labels are put on by hand (apologies in advance for any crooked labels).

Craft Peanut Butter has everything to do with the love and creativity we put into each recipe, we've tried hundreds of versions, a ton of crazy variations and if anything we are never short on new ideas. We look forward to offering new flavors as well as seasonal spreads (like"Pumpkin Spice" or  "Gingerbread") in the future.

When does my peanut butter expire?
Will it be around long enough to worry about that? Seriously though, you have at least 10 months to finish it. Best By Date is marked on each jar.

Do I need to refrigerate my jar(s)?
We suggest refrigeration after opening because we do not use preservatives and storing it in a cold place will help to slow the natural separation process. Bringing your nut butter to room temperature will make for a more spreadable texture. If you would rather not refrigerate, we suggest storing in a cool dark place.

Where else can I find products by the Nutty Peanut?
Hop on over to the FIND US tab for all the info. Also, we encourage you to tell your favorite shop you want them to bring in THE NUTTY PEANUT.

Where can I follow you on social media?
We appreciate your support and a grateful to have you share us with your friends, you can follow us on facebook, twitter and instagram. Also we'd encourage you to sign up on our email list for all things TEAM NUTTY!

Why must I "STIR WELL"?
You won't find any PALM OIL or other stabilizers in our products to prevent natural oil separation. Some of our products use 100% Organic extracts that will leave a bitter taste if not properly stirred in. Be sure to get all the way down to the bottom and stir it up well to ensure the best flavor and texture.

What is Organic Extract?
The Nutty Peanut will only ever use Organic Extracts which are water soluble flavors made in a base of Organic Ethyl Alcohol. These all natural Flavor Extracts are Certified, Organic, Food Grade, Kosher, Vegan, Gluten Free, and contain NO Allergens. Furthermore, we assure you that they are all Diacetyl FREE as well... why, because we eat it too.

Don't just take our word for it, see what others had to say.

This stuff is delicious! I love the creative flavor combos. Most of them are even safe to share with my dog and he goes "nutty" when I get the jar out. The Wake Up Nutty, which is blended with Death Wish coffee grinds is my favorite. Lucky for me that's the one I cannot share with my pup. I usually eat it by the spoonfuls, no need for bread. But I do love the sandwich creations I've had at their pop up events. All interactions I've had with staff have been awesome. I've messaged them a few times on FB and received a quick response. I'd highly recommend this to anyone who even only likes peanut butter a little bit.

The Nutty Peanut is the Best Artisan Peanut Butter ever. Their Combinations are extremely creative and delicious. Flavor balance and ratio is perfect. Their sandwiches are an upscale version of any childhood peanut butter sandwich. It’s a must taste for everyone!

If you love peanut butter, then you'll love the Nutty Peanut. They have the best unique flavors that's a great start to your morning or anytime during your day. Best of all, there are great people behind this business. You won't go wrong.

Great products, I’ve tried several varieties and love them all. If you have an opportunity take advantage of their many events they attend and try it for yourself. You will be hooked!

Really good peanut butter and they also make amazing peanut butter themed sandwiches!

Delicious! Owner Mike is a great guy and really knows his peanut butter!

I must say that I enjoyed the taste of each one. To pick a favorite would be difficult as each is it's own unique character and I can see myself indulging in any one of them at any given time. My childern enjoyed them all, as did my husband, who isn't exactly a big pb fan.

These are all a must try for any PB lover!
They each have their own unique taste, texture, and flavor to the palate. It is to difficult for me to choose one over another. It all depends on what your looking for at the moment. Absolutely love them all. Loved the "Wake Up Nutty" on pumpernickel bread with a cup of coffee on the side. Great job!

Where Else Can You Find The Nutty Peanut

DUE TO CORONAVIRUS PLEASE CHECK BEFORE ATTENDING